The Short Answer
When choosing a real estate investment strategy, it’s essential to understand the key differences between house flipping vs renting properties. These two real estate investing approaches cater to different investor profiles, each with its own set of advantages and challenges. House flipping is an active, hands-on strategy that requires significant upfront capital and involves managing renovations to quickly sell a property for profit. This approach typically results in a higher, but riskier, return on investment and comes with higher tax liabilities due to short-term capital gains.
In contrast, renting offers a more passive, long-term income stream with lower initial costs and ongoing property management responsibilities. Rental properties provide steady monthly income, benefit from gradual property appreciation, and offer tax advantages that can enhance long-term returns. Ultimately, the best strategy depends on your personal skills, financial situation, and investment goals.
Jump To
Those who are choosing a real estate investing strategy to do, should first consider the differences between flipping vs renting. These differences highlight the key factors that will help investors decide which strategy is best for them. From time availability, to upfront capital and tax benefits, these strategies offer vastly different way to generate a good return on your investment so it’s important to choose the one that best suits your investment goals, personal financial situation, and skills.
Key Differences Between Flipping vs Renting
| Flipping Houses | Renting |
|---|---|
| Active income | Passive income |
| Higher upfront costs | Lower upfront costs |
| Property management not needed | Property management required |
| Short-term property appreciation | Long-term property appreciation |
| Quick ROI and a lump sum | Gradual ROI and monthly income |
| Short-term capital gains tax | Passive income taxed |
Difference 1: Active vs Passive Income
House flipping involves finding a property, often one that is in distress, and renovating it to improve its value before selling it again for a profit. This requires managing the flipping process in a hands-on way, from choosing the projects that need to be done, to budgets and timelines. Then, the property needs to be sold, which again requires active investing through finding an agent, getting the property listed and going through the selling process. In other words, flipping houses provides an active income for investors.
Renting, on the other hand is a passive investing strategy whereby a home is bought, and then rented out to earn a monthly rental income which is great for cash flow. The management of the property can be done through a property management company, which leaves the real estate investor free to earn a passive income without having to be hands-on.
Difference 2: Higher vs Lower Upfront Costs
House flipping typically has higher upfront costs, because this investment strategy requires providing the funds for purchasing a house, then doing the necessary repairs and renovations to improve the market value of the property.
In contrast, rental properties have lower upfront costs as the purchase is the main cost, and extension renovations aren’t immediately necessary. This makes it easier to enter the market with less capital, allowing for a more gradual investment approach.
Difference 3: Property Management Requirements
The property management requirements for house flipping and renting differ significantly due to the nature of each investment strategy. Flipping houses doesn’t require any form of property management as the home is bought, upgraded, then sold immediately. The idea is not to hold the property, get tenants in or do anything other than sell for a profit once it has been upgraded. These are short-term, project-based investments which require investors to be hands-on, until the property is sold, after which their involvement is finished and no management of the property is required.
Rental properties however, requires ongoing property management to some degree, to manage the day to day involvement of tenants. This includes finding and screening tenants, handling maintenance requests, collecting rent, and addressing any tenant issues that arise. Property management is an extra set of expenses which take away from the rental income received each month and impact cash flow, however it is a necessary and continuous responsibility that comes with rental properties.
Difference 4: Property Appreciation
Property appreciation plays a big part in the choice of strategy for real estate investors. While property appreciation is a factor for both house flipping and rental properties, it looks quite different in each. For house flipping, the focus is more around improving the market value of the house so that the appreciation is immediate. While rental property owners are in it for the long haul, and there property appreciation happens gradually over time.
While those who flip houses can experience immediate property appreciation to an extent, rental investors benefit from both ongoing income and the eventual appreciation, but they must be patient and willing to ride out market fluctuations to fully realize the property’s potential value.
Difference 5: Returns on Investment
The differences in return on investment (ROI) between house flipping and renting are shaped by the distinct timelines and risk profiles of each strategy. Flipping houses offers investors a quick return on their investment and an active income. Most house flipping projects take about 6 months, which means that investors who choose to flip houses are likely to complete their project and realize their profits within a year. The potential ROI on these projects is high, as investors can earn a large profit if they can sell the property at the right price.
While rental properties provide consistent, predictable rental income (passive income) each month through monthly rent payments, this is a longer-term investment option which means it will take longer for rental property owners to recoup what they invested in the property. While the ROI on rental properties may not be as dramatic as house flipping initially, it includes potential appreciation in property value and various tax advantages, along with the monthly rent.
Difference 6: Taxes
House flippers are typically subject to short-term capital gains taxes on their flipping profits, which can be taxed at rates exceeding 25%, depending on their income bracket and the duration of property ownership. Due to the fact that flipping houses often involves buying and selling within a short period, these gains are treated as ordinary income, resulting in higher tax liabilities.
On the other hand, rental property income is generally taxed at lower rates, often around 15%, as it’s considered passive income. Additionally, rental property owners can take advantage of tax benefits like deductions for expenses such as mortgage interest, property management, maintenance, and depreciation, which can significantly reduce their taxable income. It’s important to note the taxes that are paid when you sell a rental property as well.
Which Investing Strategy Suits You Best?
Deciding between flipping a house and investing in rental property is a personal choice for each real estate investor. Both real estate investing strategies can be profitable, but the best option depends on your preferences and skills.
If you enjoy tackling projects and have a knack for do-it-yourself home upgrades, house flipping might be your ideal path. This approach requires a significant upfront investment, not only to purchase the property but also to renovate it. The goal is to sell the property for a higher price than the combined cost of acquisition and repairs, resulting in a lump sum profit.
On the other hand, if you prefer a steadier income stream with less immediate physical labor, rental property investing could be more suitable. By renting out a property, you earn a consistent income over time, as long as you maintain occupancy with tenants. This method offers a potentially endless revenue stream, provided the property remains desirable and well-managed.
It’s crucial to consider how each investment method generates income. Flipping houses involves a larger initial financial outlay and returns the investment through a single, often substantial, payout upon sale. Rental property, conversely, spreads the return over an extended period through monthly rent payments, offering ongoing income with less upfront effort.